5388 Bluff Drive, Jerusalem

$ 4,399,000
5388 West Bluff Drive, ,

Overview

  • Updated On:
  • August 25, 2026
  • 3,777.00 ft2 Interior
  • 4 Bedrooms
  • 4 Bathrooms
  • 4.81 ac Acres

Description

Magical… over 18 years in the making, 5388 West Bluff Drive is a Keuka Lake legacy property—where craftsmanship, character, and an exceptional setting converge. Poised on 173 feet of point lakefront with 4+ acres, this custom residence offers 3700+ square feet of considered living space across four levels. Created with an uncompromising eye toward quality, every element reflects craftsmanship, authenticity, and intention. The custom kitchen and dining area are framed by expansive windows, a wood burning masonry fireplace for cooking or ambiance, stone features and vaulted reclaimed wood ceilings. Beyond, an authentic pub creates an intimate gathering space, opening to a covered porch for lakeside entertaining. The main living area is anchored by two story wood-burning fireplace, with a charming loft reading nook. Just beyond lies an expansive screened three-season room for effortless indoor-outdoor living. With heaters, retractable screens, an equipped outdoor kitchen, and third wood-burning fireplace, all overlooking the water, this is a room made for lingering. Built as his own residence, this home reflects the discerning eye of a high-end builder, where no detail was overlooked, embodying timeless craftsmanship. The upper levels provide exceptional accommodations for family & guests. Two bedrooms, a full bath, and laundry occupy the second level; the upper floor offers a large bedroom with en-suite bath and walk-in closet. On the lowest, lakefront level, the primary suite is spectacular. Expansive accordion doors with an electric screen open directly to an additional outdoor kitchen, sunken hot tub, and grassy beach—creating a private retreat where indoor & outdoor living nearly disappear. Let the waves soothe you to sleep. Five stone fireplaces! Every corner celebrates the Keuka Lake lifestyle: an extraordinary connection to the water. A permanent timber-framed dock with covered boat lift, beach house, and outdoor shower complete the waterfront experience. A substantial heated garage provides additional work space & storage along with an upstairs premium gym. The residence remains unmistakably at home on West Bluff Drive.

Property Location

Street: 5388 West Bluff Drive
Tax Area: Jerusalem
County:
Postal City: Keuka Park
State: NY
Zip: 14478
School District: Penn Yan
Waterfront Y/N: Yes
HOA Y/N: No
Directions: Property is located at 5388 West Bluff Drive, can be accessed through Pepper Road or from Skyline Drive. There is year round access to West Bluff Drive. Sign at entry, park at garage.

Property Details

Property Id: 1244035
Price: $ 4,399,000
Property Size: 3,777.00 ft2
Property Lot Size: 4.81 ac
Bedrooms: 4
Bathrooms: 4
Waterfront Y/N: Yes
Architectural Style: Craftsman, HistoricAntique
Basement: Full, Finished, WalkOutAccess
Bathrooms Full: 3
Bathrooms Half: 1
Bathrooms Total: 4
Bedrooms Total: 4
Below Grade Sq Ft: 1117
Building Sq Ft Total: 3777
Cooling: Ductless
Directions: Property is located at 5388 West Bluff Drive, can be accessed through Pepper Road or from Skyline Drive. There is year round access to West Bluff Drive. Sign at entry, park at garage.
Electric: CircuitBreakers
Elementary School District: Penn Yan
Fireplaces Total: 5
Flooring: Hardwood, Tile, Varies
Foundation Details: Poured
Frontage Length: 173
Furnished: Furnished
Garage Spaces: 3
Heating: Ductless, Electric, Propane, HotWater, Radiant
High School District: Penn Yan
Latitude: 42.540512
Laundry Features: InBasement, UpperLevel
List Office Name: Wine Trail Properties, LLC
List Office Phone: 315-536-8004
List Price: 4399000
Listing Id: R1707071
Living Sq Ft: 3777
Longitude: -77.142031
Lot Features: Rectangular, RectangularLot
Acres: 4.805
Lot Acres: 4.805
Lot Dimensions: 173X200
Main Level Bathrooms: 1
Middle School District: Penn Yan
Status: Active
Patio & Porch Features: Covered, Porch, Screened
Photos: 50
Possession: CloseOfEscrow
Postal City: Keuka Park
Zip Code: 14478
Description: Magical… over 18 years in the making, 5388 West Bluff Drive is a Keuka Lake legacy property—where craftsmanship, character, and an exceptional setting converge. Poised on 173 feet of point lakefront with 4+ acres, this custom residence offers 3700+ square feet of considered living space across four levels. Created with an uncompromising eye toward quality, every element reflects craftsmanship, authenticity, and intention. The custom kitchen and dining area are framed by expansive windows, a wood burning masonry fireplace for cooking or ambiance, stone features and vaulted reclaimed wood ceilings. Beyond, an authentic pub creates an intimate gathering space, opening to a covered porch for lakeside entertaining. The main living area is anchored by two story wood-burning fireplace, with a charming loft reading nook. Just beyond lies an expansive screened three-season room for effortless indoor-outdoor living. With heaters, retractable screens, an equipped outdoor kitchen, and third wood-burning fireplace, all overlooking the water, this is a room made for lingering. Built as his own residence, this home reflects the discerning eye of a high-end builder, where no detail was overlooked, embodying timeless craftsmanship. The upper levels provide exceptional accommodations for family & guests. Two bedrooms, a full bath, and laundry occupy the second level; the upper floor offers a large bedroom with en-suite bath and walk-in closet. On the lowest, lakefront level, the primary suite is spectacular. Expansive accordion doors with an electric screen open directly to an additional outdoor kitchen, sunken hot tub, and grassy beach—creating a private retreat where indoor & outdoor living nearly disappear. Let the waves soothe you to sleep. Five stone fireplaces! Every corner celebrates the Keuka Lake lifestyle: an extraordinary connection to the water. A permanent timber-framed dock with covered boat lift, beach house, and outdoor shower complete the waterfront experience. A substantial heated garage provides additional work space & storage along with an upstairs premium gym. The residence remains unmistakably at home on West Bluff Drive.
Road Frontage: MainThoroughfare
Roof: Architectural, Metal, Shingle
Rooms Total: 16
StateOrProvince: NY
Stories: 4
Street Prefix: W
Street Name: Bluff
Street Number: 5388
Street Number Numeric: 5388
Street Suffix: Drive
Total Taxes: 23025
Assessed Value: 1608200
Town: Not Applicable
Utilities: HighSpeedInternetAvailable
View: Water
Water Source: Lake, River
Waterfront Features: BeachAccess, BoatRampLiftAccess, DockAccess, Lake
Year Built: 2026
YearBuiltDetails: Existing

Amenities and Features

Other Features
Bar
Barbecue
Basement Y/N 1
CathedralCeilings
CeilingFans
CentralVacuum
ConcreteDriveway
Dishwasher
Dock
Dryer
EatInKitchen
ExhaustFan
Furnished
GasOven
GasRange
GuestAccommodations
Has a Main Level Bedroom
Has a View
Has Cooling System
Has Fireplace
Has Garage
Has Heating System
Has Waterfront
HotTubSpa
KitchenIsland
Loft
Main Level Bedrooms 1
MainLevelPrimary
Microwave
NaturalWoodwork
Porch
PrimarySuite
PropaneTankOwned
PropaneWaterHeater
QuartzCounters
RangeHood
Refrigerator
SeeRemarks
SeparateFormalLivingRoom
Skylights
SolidSurfaceCounters
Washer
WaterPurifierOwned

Map

Courtesy Of : Wine Trail Properties, LLC
315-536-8004

The data relating to real estate on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) Program of NYSAMLS’s. Real estate listings held by firms other than Edelweiss Properties Realtors, LLC are marked with the IDX logo and include the Listing Brokerage’s Name and Phone Number.

All information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. All properties are subject to prior sale, change, or withdrawal. Neither the Listing Brokerage nor Edelweiss Properties Realtors, LLC shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints, and shall be held totally harmless. All rights reserved.

Payment Calculator

$ 22,554.54
per month
  • Principal and Interest
  • Property Tax
  • HOA fee
$ 17,055.79

Page Views Statistics

Schedule a tour

Fri 04 Sep
Sat 05 Sep
Sun 06 Sep
Mon 07 Sep
Tue 08 Sep
Wed 09 Sep
Thu 10 Sep
Fri 11 Sep
Sat 12 Sep
Sun 13 Sep
In Person
Video Chat
Your information

Contact Me

Schedule a showing?

Property Reviews

No reviews found.
You need to login in order to post a review

Similar Listings

Land
Active
$ 168,000

3376B NYS Route 54A Lot B Highway, Jerusalem

ONE of FOUR adjoining building lots above Keuka Lake’s north end. Location, Location, Loca ...
Residential
Active
$ 210,000

2555 Willett Road Ext, Jerusalem

9+ acres. Cabin. Barn. Location. Opportunity. Go! Set across two parcels, the property fea ...
Beds:
1
Baths:
1
Sq Ft:
750.00 ft2

Compare Listings

The team at Edelweiss Properties