200 S West Street, Geneva City

Description: This beautifully preserved historic home blends timeless craftsmanship with extensive modern updates completed over the last five years. Ideally located within walking distance to HWS Colleges, Wegmans, Downtown Geneva, Seneca Lake/Pier, and Jefferson Park, the property offers both charm and convenience. Rich with original character, the home showcases stunning woodwork, ornate mantels, intricate tilework, refinished hardwood floors, and exquisite leaded glass windows that simply cannot be replicated today. Major improvements provide peace of mind and modern comfort throughout. In 2025, the exterior was upgraded with new vinyl siding, gutters, and 21 replacement windows fitted with custom blinds. The showstopping front porch was completely rebuilt and serves as a true centerpiece of the home. Step through the stunning new glass and wood front door into a spacious foyer filled with historic elegance. The front parlor flows seamlessly into the main living room, where the original fireplace, mantle, and tile surround create a striking focal point. Modern improvements include new drywall, a 200-amp electrical panel upgrade, and a brand-new furnace and central A/C installed in 2025. The formal dining room features beautiful wainscoting and a picture ledge surround. Beyond the charming butler’s pantry and remodeled half bath, you’ll find an oversized eat-in kitchen with newly enlarged windows overlooking the private backyard oasis. Outside, the fully fenced vinyl privacy yard is complemented by upgraded landscaping and a beautiful patio installed in 2023, creating the perfect setting for entertaining or relaxing. This already spacious two-story home could easily become 2, 700+ sqft by utilizing the full walk-up attic! Upstairs, an open sitting room with original leaded glass windows overlooks the vibrant neighborhood below. The basement is clean, dry, and ideal for storage. Homes with this level of historic integrity, craftsmanship, and thoughtful modernization are increasingly rare. Come experience the care, character, and countless improvements that make this historic gem truly one of a kind. Open House Saturday 5/30 1-2:30PM.